VAT Food Nuance (Nov 26)

Regular readers may remember Skinade. Last November we reported that Bottled Science had been given permission to take its liquid collagen drink to the Upper Tribunal, and the decision is now in. The Upper Tribunal has set aside the FTT’s ruling that Skinade wasn’t food, with around £1.25m of VAT riding on the outcome.

Don’t pop the corks just yet, though.

The FTT had decided Skinade was a beauty product rather than a food, leaning heavily on how it was packaged and sold: clinical-looking boxes, beauty trade shows and cosmetics awards, rather than anything you’d find in the food aisle.

The appeal was won on a point nobody argued first time round, and it comes from a familiar source: the giant marshmallows. In Innovative Bites, the Court of Appeal decided that when the food rules say one thing “includes” another, they mean it. The legislation says food includes drink, so if Skinade is a drink, it’s food, unless that would be absurd or it falls into one of the standard-rated exceptions such as other beverages.

As the FTT never had to decide whether Skinade was a drink, the case now goes back to a fresh tribunal to answer exactly that. It’s less obvious than it sounds. The Upper Tribunal pointed out that liquid medicines are swallowed, but you wouldn’t necessarily call them drinks.

There’s a sting in the tail too. HMRC had previously accepted that Skinade wasn’t a beverage, and the Upper Tribunal has said it’s only fair to let them revisit that. So the next hearing could decide that Skinade is a drink, and a standard-rated one at that.

Bottled Science lost its other two arguments. The Upper Tribunal described the FTT’s original analysis as exemplary and confirmed that the way a product is marketed can carry a great deal of weight. It’s the same ground we looked at in Minerva in September, where the FTT found a different range of collagen drinks wasn’t food, so the “is it food?” route is still proving hard going for suppliers.

For anyone selling functional drinks, supplements or shots, the questions are now whether the product is a drink and, if it is, whether it’s a beverage, and how it’s presented still counts at both stages. It’s also a reminder to put every argument forward at the first hearing, as the Tribunal made clear it won’t normally allow new ones later. We’ll be keeping a close eye on the new hearing.

If this affects your business or your clients, please get in touch with your usual VITA contact.

Next
Next

VAT & Holding Companies